You can't order online, and you may struggle finding the front door, and yet you'll do it all again for that pizza. The crust is great, and the ingredients all seam high quality. And those cinnamon bread sticks are fantastic!
Kelsey
-
November 05, 2025
Clean restaurant. Quick and super friendly service! Staff was kind to my daughter(big plus in my book). Food was delicious! We only got a pepperoni pizza and a root beer since it's just the two of us. I want to come back and try the chicken bacon ranch pizza, cheese sticks, and Oreo bread sticks sometime.
Remington Wickham
-
February 05, 2026
An incredible hidden gem in Saratoga. The food was superb. The pizza they sell is great, but the Indian food is SPECTACULAR. We were thoughtfully waited on by Madan, who talked us through the menu. I was grateful for his help and for the incredible food cooked by his remarkable staff. I’m looking forward to going back. I’m begging everyone to give their Indian food a shot! It’s the gem that Saratoga Springs desperately needs.
Calvan Johnson
-
December 27, 2023
Locally owned and operated pizzeria offers quick, tasty, and affordable pizza as well as chicken wings, scones, and fries! They recently moved just east across the street from their previous location into a brand new building
The 10” inch pizza (slightly larger than a typical personal pizza, feeds two or feeds one very hungry) comes in at $5, and a 14” inch pie will cost you $9, with toppings extra.
The crust was firm on the outside and fluffy on the inside, the sauce was flavorful, and the cheese and toppings were fresh and plentiful. Pizza included a free ranch sauce cup for dipping!
The store was clean and modern but provides very little dine-in seating. The staff was friendly and helpful!
Overall great place to get a pizza!
Kayla Davis
-
April 10, 2026
We called today to bring to light tha last 3 times weve gotten pizza it hasnt been cut. Were regulars at Tennys so we waited a few times to bring it up. We were told that the pizzas are always cut. I just wanted to leave these pictures to show, theyre not always cut. It felt like the complaint was dismissed rather than just acknowledged and a mission statement. (For the record my last review was 5 stars!)
Our Address
282 Crossroads Blvd, Saratoga Springs, UT 84045, USA
Claim Listing: Tenney’s Pizza
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
You can't order online, and you may struggle finding the front door, and yet you'll do it all again for that pizza. The crust is great, and the ingredients all seam high quality. And those cinnamon bread sticks are fantastic!
Clean restaurant. Quick and super friendly service! Staff was kind to my daughter(big plus in my book). Food was delicious! We only got a pepperoni pizza and a root beer since it's just the two of us. I want to come back and try the chicken bacon ranch pizza, cheese sticks, and Oreo bread sticks sometime.
An incredible hidden gem in Saratoga. The food was superb. The pizza they sell is great, but the Indian food is SPECTACULAR. We were thoughtfully waited on by Madan, who talked us through the menu. I was grateful for his help and for the incredible food cooked by his remarkable staff. I’m looking forward to going back. I’m begging everyone to give their Indian food a shot! It’s the gem that Saratoga Springs desperately needs.
Locally owned and operated pizzeria offers quick, tasty, and affordable pizza as well as chicken wings, scones, and fries! They recently moved just east across the street from their previous location into a brand new building The 10” inch pizza (slightly larger than a typical personal pizza, feeds two or feeds one very hungry) comes in at $5, and a 14” inch pie will cost you $9, with toppings extra. The crust was firm on the outside and fluffy on the inside, the sauce was flavorful, and the cheese and toppings were fresh and plentiful. Pizza included a free ranch sauce cup for dipping! The store was clean and modern but provides very little dine-in seating. The staff was friendly and helpful! Overall great place to get a pizza!
We called today to bring to light tha last 3 times weve gotten pizza it hasnt been cut. Were regulars at Tennys so we waited a few times to bring it up. We were told that the pizzas are always cut. I just wanted to leave these pictures to show, theyre not always cut. It felt like the complaint was dismissed rather than just acknowledged and a mission statement. (For the record my last review was 5 stars!)