Locally owned and operated pizzeria offers quick, tasty, and affordable pizza as well as chicken wings, scones, and fries! They recently moved just east across the street from their previous location into a brand new building
The 10” inch pizza (slightly larger than a typical personal pizza, feeds two or feeds one very hungry) comes in at $5, and a 14” inch pie will cost you $9, with toppings extra.
The crust was firm on the outside and fluffy on the inside, the sauce was flavorful, and the cheese and toppings were fresh and plentiful. Pizza included a free ranch sauce cup for dipping!
The store was clean and modern but provides very little dine-in seating. The staff was friendly and helpful!
Overall great place to get a pizza!
Sharon Turner
-
December 16, 2023
Pizza was fine. Employees were kind.
However, the boneless wings we ordered were 2 giant pieces of chicken breast. lol just a breast dropped in the fryer! Also one of them was undercooked.
wasinee sripantong
-
April 06, 2025
used to be our favorite pizza place… but suddenly there is an entirely new staff…who tried to charge my husband twice for our order, the pizza randomly changed into thin crust only…the large fries are literally half the fries they were before, and the wings are tiny. not sure what happened but if its the same next time…we will never go back again.
J S
-
April 09, 2025
Tenney’s gets an extra star because it’s local in a town that’s overstuffed with boring chains.
That said, the pizza is just good enough — nothing really special about it compared to anything else around here.
My wife does love the keto crust, so that’s good :)
Austin Hale
-
December 02, 2021
POSITIVES: the customer service is pretty good when it came to fulfilling our specific requests. Nice cozy little place to sit and enjoy lunch or dinner. The cheese on both the pizza and cheesey bread was phenomenal! Those bread slices were very airy and fluffy, which was great.
NEGATIVES: two major things that let me down: the sauce on the pizza (which might be the same as the dipping sauce for the cheesey bread), which tastes almost too sweet. It's flavor was closer to ketchup than pizza sauce, although the consistency was fine. The crust was a bit of a let down. It reminded me of Little Caesars. Just a meh crust with little flavor or excitement to it. Also, the price for what you get seemed a little steep.
PRICE: $9 for a large, 1 topping pizza. $6 for a small cheese breadsticks.
Our Address
282 Crossroads Blvd, Saratoga Springs, UT 84045, USA
Claim Listing: Tenney’s Pizza
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
Locally owned and operated pizzeria offers quick, tasty, and affordable pizza as well as chicken wings, scones, and fries! They recently moved just east across the street from their previous location into a brand new building The 10” inch pizza (slightly larger than a typical personal pizza, feeds two or feeds one very hungry) comes in at $5, and a 14” inch pie will cost you $9, with toppings extra. The crust was firm on the outside and fluffy on the inside, the sauce was flavorful, and the cheese and toppings were fresh and plentiful. Pizza included a free ranch sauce cup for dipping! The store was clean and modern but provides very little dine-in seating. The staff was friendly and helpful! Overall great place to get a pizza!
Pizza was fine. Employees were kind. However, the boneless wings we ordered were 2 giant pieces of chicken breast. lol just a breast dropped in the fryer! Also one of them was undercooked.
used to be our favorite pizza place… but suddenly there is an entirely new staff…who tried to charge my husband twice for our order, the pizza randomly changed into thin crust only…the large fries are literally half the fries they were before, and the wings are tiny. not sure what happened but if its the same next time…we will never go back again.
Tenney’s gets an extra star because it’s local in a town that’s overstuffed with boring chains. That said, the pizza is just good enough — nothing really special about it compared to anything else around here. My wife does love the keto crust, so that’s good :)
POSITIVES: the customer service is pretty good when it came to fulfilling our specific requests. Nice cozy little place to sit and enjoy lunch or dinner. The cheese on both the pizza and cheesey bread was phenomenal! Those bread slices were very airy and fluffy, which was great. NEGATIVES: two major things that let me down: the sauce on the pizza (which might be the same as the dipping sauce for the cheesey bread), which tastes almost too sweet. It's flavor was closer to ketchup than pizza sauce, although the consistency was fine. The crust was a bit of a let down. It reminded me of Little Caesars. Just a meh crust with little flavor or excitement to it. Also, the price for what you get seemed a little steep. PRICE: $9 for a large, 1 topping pizza. $6 for a small cheese breadsticks.